Top 5 TDIU Questions Veterans Ask – Answered by a VA Attorney

 Posted on July 04, 2025 in Uncategorized

Understanding how VA Total Disability Individual Unemployability (TDIU) benefits work is vital for veterans who find themselves unable to engage in substantial gainful employment due to service-connected disabilities. However, the TDIU process is often complicated by misunderstandings about age, educational background, income thresholds, and interactions with other benefits like Social Security. Below are five of the most frequently asked questions about TDIU, each answered to provide clearer, actionable guidance for your VA claim.

1. Does Age Affect My VA Unemployability Claim?

One of the most common misconceptions concerns the role of age in VA unemployability determinations. The VA is strictly prohibited from considering your age when evaluating eligibility for TDIU. Whether you’re 24 or 94, the decisive question is whether your service-connected disabilities—not your age—prevent you from maintaining substantial gainful employment. The focus is on your ability to work due to your service-connected conditions, not how long you’ve been out of the workforce or your current age.

2. Do I Need to File a Formal TDIU Claim or Will the VA "Infer" It?

Many veterans mistakenly believe that the VA will automatically "infer" a claim for unemployability if evidence of unemployability appears in the course of an increased rating claim. Legally, the VA is required to do this based on the precedent set in Rice v. Shinseki. If evidence of unemployability arises during the consideration of a disability rating increase, a TDIU claim should be inferred, even without filing VA Form 21-8940 (the formal TDIU application). In practice, though, the VA rarely infers these claims. It's highly recommended that you proactively file VA Form 21-8940 if you believe you qualify for TDIU, rather than waiting on the VA to initiate the process for you. If granted TDIU later, you may be eligible for an earlier effective date if it’s shown the VA should have inferred the claim.

3. Can the VA Say I’m Able to Work in an Office When My Background is Physical Labor?

The VA must consider your occupational and educational background when deciding on unemployability. If your work history involves only physical labor, and you lack the experience or education for sedentary (office) jobs, the VA should not assume you can transition to such work. Disabilities affecting your capacity to sit, use a computer, or interact with others (such as mental health issues or physical impairments with hands or back) must be weighed. It’s crucial to demonstrate how all your service-connected disabilities, not just their physical or mental nature, affect typical workplace functions, including sedentary roles.

Questions? Schedule a free consultation at https://calendly.com/vetlawoffice

4. Is There an Income Limit for TDIU and Can I Work at All?

There’s no set income "limit" for TDIU, but eligibility hinges on being unable to maintain "substantial gainful employment" due to your service-connected disabilities. The VA defines this as the inability to earn above the federal poverty threshold. Simply choosing a job below that line does not guarantee TDIU; the question is whether your disabilities actually prevent you from earning more. Some veterans are allowed "marginal employment," but this is a nuanced argument and depends on the circumstances. Earning over the poverty line generally makes you ineligible, unless your work is protected or "sheltered" (i.e., not competitive employment).

5. Can I Receive TDIU and Social Security Benefits Together?

Yes, you can receive both TDIU and Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) or regular Social Security retirement benefits. These are not considered "earned income" and do not preclude eligibility for TDIU. However, Supplemental Security Income (SSI)—a needs-based Social Security program—may be affected if you’re awarded TDIU, as both are income-tested. TDIU does not affect your eligibility for SSDI or Social Security retirement, but could impact SSI.

Optimizing Your Unemployability (TDIU) Claim:

• File Proactively: Don’t wait for the VA to infer your TDIU claim—complete and submit VA Form 21-8940.

• Document Functional Impairment: Gather medical evidence and lay statements that show how your disabilities limit all employment types, including sedentary roles.

• Consider past work and education: Illustrate why your background makes it unreasonable to expect you to transition careers due to your limitations.

• Clarify Income Sources: Understand the difference between earned income and Social Security; report all sources accurately.

• Consult a VA-accredited representative: Early, expert guidance can help avoid errors that may delay or jeopardize your claim.

Navigating the VA Unemployability process is never easy. Understanding these common concerns and how the VA reviews TDIU claims can make a substantial difference in your outcome. If you have questions about applying or appealing a denied TDIU claim, seek help from qualified VA disability advocates to protect your benefits and your future.

Schedule a free consultation with our team to discuss your VA Unemployability claim: https://calendly.com/vetlawoffice